Vermont should claim its share of the federal scholarship tax credit

Clara Morrison Education

Every year, Vermonters send their federal tax dollars to Washington and hope some of that money finds its way back. Now, a new federal program offers a rare chance to send it straight to Vermont students, but only if Governor Scott chooses to take part.

The federal tax credit scholarship lets any taxpayer donate up to $1,700 (or $3,400 for married couples filing jointly) to a private nonprofit scholarship-granting organization and receive a dollar-for-dollar credit on their federal taxes. Those organizations award scholarships directly to students for tuition, tutoring, after-school programs, summer learning and other educational costs. Because donors are reimbursed through the federal tax code, it doesn’t cost Vermont families a dime, and not a dollar comes out of our state budget or our Education Fund.

Participation takes two steps. The governor must file Vermont’s election with the IRS by January first, 2027, and the state must then submit its list of qualifying scholarship organizations by February 15th. If Vermont stays out, Vermonters can still claim the credit, but their donations will flow to scholarship organizations in New Hampshire, New York or the dozens of other participating states, guaranteeing that Vermont students don’t benefit.

A law signed earlier this year complicates the second step. Legislators limited eligible organizations to a narrow set of tutoring and after-school programs, but federal rules require participating states to list every qualifying organization and bar them from adding stricter requirements. The law anticipated a conflict like this: if the Attorney General finds any part of it invalid under federal rules, the state may not submit its list until the Legislature passes legislation addressing the problem. Whether Vermont students benefit in 2027 will likely depend on whether lawmakers revisit the law early in the session that begins in January. The first step, however, is for Governor Scott to opt in, and he has yet to do so.

He would be in good company: the governors on either side of Vermont, from opposite parties, have both opted in. New Hampshire Governor Kelly Ayotte joined in January. On October 9, New York Governor Kathy Hochul, a Democrat and a firm supporter of public education, announced that her state would participate:

“I’ve been clear from the start that New York would participate in the federal scholarship tax credit program if, and only if, all schools and students, including those in our public schools, could benefit,” Hochul said. “After a careful review of the federal regulations, we believe this program has the potential to bring millions of additional dollars to New York students and families without taking a single dollar from public schools or our state or local budgets.”

Despite opponents like the the National Education Association calling the credit a voucher program that diverts resources from public schools, scholarships can actually fund tutoring, after-school and summer programs for public school students, and Treasury’s rules actually require states to include the organizations that serve them, making the program a new source of support for every child, in every kind of school.

Teachers seem to understand this better than their national union. A national survey of teachers found that 70% support their state opting in, and among NEA members, two-thirds supported participation, compared with only about one in five who opposed it. Public school teachers know what an extra tutor or a summer program can mean for a student who is falling behind.

Every Vermont child deserves the chance to learn and catch up, no matter what type of school they attend. Governor Scott can keep that possibility open by filing Vermont’s election before January first. Filing costs the state nothing, and it would give the Legislature the opportunity to correct state law so that Vermont students can participate in the program’s first year.